RELIABLE.
NONPARTISAN.
EMPOWERING.

  • HOME
  • 2016 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION - MENU
    • 2016 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION - HOME
    • GET STARTED
      • Quiz - Find Your Candidate Match! Compare Candidate Positions Side-by-Side
    • ISSUES AND CANDIDATE STATEMENTS
      • Crime & Justice Economy & Taxes Education Elections Energy Foreign Policy Guns / Second Amendment Health Care, Abortion, & End of Life Issues Immigration Labor & Wages Marijuana & Alcohol Military & War on Terror Race Science & Environment Sex & Gender
    • RECOMMENDED
      • Did You Know? The Electoral College: Top 3 Pros and Cons Pros and Cons of Donald Trump's Cabinet Picks Differences in Conservative and Liberal Brains Candidate Finances Candidate Position Changes US Political Parties Presidential Election History from 1789 to 2012 How to Become the US President: A Step-by-Step Guide Order of Presidential Succession Top 10 Most Surprising Things in the 2016 Presidential Candidates' Online Stores How to Register to Vote
    • DIG DEEPER
      • 2016 Presidential Election Results ProCon.org Criteria for Inclusion as a Presidential Candidate Glossary Jeb Bush - Positions Ben Carson - Positions Chris Christie - Positions Hillary Clinton - Positions Ted Cruz - Positions Carly Fiorina - Positions Lindsey Graham - Positions Mike Huckabee - Positions John Kasich - Positions Martin O'Malley - Positions Rand Paul - Positions Marco Rubio - Positions Bernie Sanders - Positions Donald Trump - Positions 2012 Presidential Election Quiz
  • ISSUES WE COVER
    • MOST POPULAR
      • 2020 Presidential Election
      • Medical Marijuana
      • Gun Control
      • Homework
      • Animal Testing
      • Death Penalty
      • School Uniforms
      • Drinking Age - Lower It?
      • Abortion
      • Zoos
      • Illegal Immigration
    • HEALTH & MEDICINE
      • Medical Marijuana
      • Euthanasia & Assisted Suicide
      • Vaping E-Cigarettes
      • Vaccines for Kids
      • Milk - Is It Healthy?
      • OTC Birth Control
      • Abortion
      • Vegetarianism
      • Obesity a Disease?
      • Obamacare
      • Right to Health Care
      • Prescription Drug Ads
      • Marijuana for Pets
    • EDUCATION
      • School Uniforms
      • Standardized Tests
      • Tablets vs. Textbooks
      • College Education Worth It?
      • Teacher Tenure
      • Student Loan Debt
      • School Vouchers
      • Corporal Punishment
      • Banned Books
      • Homework
      • Free College
      • D.A.R.E (archived 6/3/13)
    • POLITICS
      • Death Penalty
      • Drinking Age - Lower It?
      • Illegal Immigration
      • Gun Control
      • Recreational Marijuana
      • Mandatory National Service
      • ACLU - Good for America?
      • Concealed Handguns
      • Sanctuary Cities
      • Under God in the Pledge
      • DACA & Dreamers
      • Dacota Pipeline
      • WTC Muslim Center (archived 6/3/13)
    • SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY
      • Animal Testing
      • Cell Phones Radiation
      • Alternative Energy vs. Fossil Fuels
      • Climate Change
      • Net Nautrality
      • Police Body Cameras
      • Bottled Water Ban
      • Zoos
      • GMOs
    • ELECTIONS & PRESIDENTS
      • 2020 Presidential Election
      • Felon Voting
      • Election Day National Holiday
      • Electoral College
      • Lowering the Voting Age to 16
      • Voting Machines
      • Ronald Reagan
      • Bill Clinton
      • 2008 Presidential Election (archived 1/19/09)
      • 2012 Presidential Election (archived 1/22/13)
      • 2016 Presidential Election (archived 1/21/17)
    • WORLD / INTERNATIONAL
      • Israeli-Palestinian Conflict
      • Cuba Embargo
      • Drone Strikes Overseas
      • Us Drone Shot Down by Iran
      • US-Iraq War (archived 12/31/11)
    • SEX & GENDER
      • Gay Marriage
      • Prostitution - Legalize It?
      • Born Gay? Origins of Sexual Orientation
    • ENTERTAINMENT & SPORTS
      • Social Media
      • Video Games and Violence
      • Drug Use in Sports
      • Binge-Watching
      • Golf - Is It a Sport?
      • Olympics
      • National Anthem Protest
      • Fighting in Hockey
      • Pokémon
      • College Football Playoffs (archived 9/18/12)
    • ECONOMY & TAXES
      • Minimum Wage
      • Gold Standard
      • Corporate Tax Rate & Jobs
      • Churches and Taxes
      • Uber & Lyft
      • Social Security Privatization
      • Daylight Savings Time
      • Universal Basic Income
      • Penny - Keep It?
      • Big Three Auto (archived 5/15/09)
      • Insider Trading by Congress (archived 4/18/12)
    • YOU MAY ALSO LIKE
      • Watch Our Videos
      • Teachers' Corner
      • Readers' Comments
      • Who Uses ProCon.org?
      • Debate Topics
      • Testimonials
      • Donors & Sponsors
    • GET INVOLVED
      • ProCon.org Events
      • Suggest a Topic
      • Cite This Page
      • Share on Social Media
      • Volunteers / Interns
  • ABOUT US
    • ABOUT US
    • HOW WE WORK
    • WATCH OUR VIDEOS
    • FAQS
    • EVENTS
    • TESTIMONIALS
    • DONORS & SPONSORS
  • TEACHERS' CORNER
  • HOME
  • |
  • FAQS
  • |
  • TESTIMONIALS
  • |
  • DONORS & SPONSORS

  • MORE
    ISSUES
 
  • ABOUT
    US
 
  • WATCH
    OUR VIDEOS
 
  • TEACHERS'
    CORNER

2016 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION
Last updated on: 3/10/2016 10:45:24 AM PST

Should Supreme Court Justice Scalia's Replacement Be Chosen by President Obama?



Pro
Clinton
Clinton

Johnson
Johnson

Con
Trump
Trump

Not Clear or Not Found
Stein
Stein






Pro (Yes)

Pro
Hillary Clinton
Hillary Clinton
Democrat

"My thoughts and prayers are with the family and friends of Justice Scalia as they mourn his sudden passing. I did not hold Justice Scalia's views, but he was a dedicated public servant who brought energy and passion to the bench.

The Republicans in the Senate and on the campaign trail who are calling for Justice Scalia's seat to remain vacant dishonor our Constitution. The Senate has a constitutional responsibility here that it cannot abdicate for partisan political reasons."

Source: Hillary Clinton, Twitter post, twitter.com, Feb. 13, 2016
Pro
Gary Johnson
Gary Johnson
Libertarian

"[T]hey should hold hearings on Obama's nominee. It's Obama's duty to provide that nomination and I think that Congress should follow through on that, which obviously they are not."

Source: Phone Interview with ProCon.org, June 14, 2016
Con (No)

Con
Donald Trump
Donald Trump
Republican

"Well, I can say this. If the President, and if I were President now I would certainly want to try and nominate a justice. I'm sure that, frankly, I'm absolutely sure that President Obama will try and do it. I hope that our Senate is going to be able -- Mitch, and the entire group, is going to be able to do something about it.

In times of delay, we could have a Diane Sykes, or you could have a Bill Pryor [two federal judges], we have some fantastic people. But this is a tremendous blow to conservatism. It's a tremendous blow, frankly to our country... I think he's going to do it whether or I'm OK with it or not. I think it's up to Mitch McConnell, and everybody else to stop it. It's called delay, delay, delay."

Source: Team Fix, "The CBS News Republican Debate Transcript, Annotated," washingtonpost.com, Feb. 13, 2016


None Found
Jill Stein
Jill Stein
Green

No positon found as of Apr. 21, 2016






FORMER CANDIDATES
(Candidates who have withdrawn or who no longer meet our criteria appear below in black and white and in alphabetical order.)



Pro
Sanders
Sanders

Con
Bush
Bush

Carson
Carson

Cruz
Cruz

Kasich
Kasich

Rubio
Rubio

Not Clear or Not Found
Christie
Christie
Fiorina
Fiorina
Graham
Graham
Huckabee
Huckabee
O'Malley
O'Malley
Paul
Paul





Pro (Yes)

Pro
Bernie Sanders
Bernie Sanders
Democrat

"[I]t is beyond my comprehension and it just speaks to the unbelievable level and unprecedented level of Republican obstructionism against Obama from day one. This is not something that is in debate. The Constitution of the United States of America provides that the president appoints, nominates a Supreme Court justice. And then the Senate holds hearings and deliberation and votes on whether or not to approve that nomination.

The idea that Republicans want to deny the president of the United States his basic constitutional right is beyond my comprehension. So I will do everything that I can to make sure that when the president makes his nomination, the Senate goes forward in as speedy a process as possible, holds the necessary hearings and hopefully appoints and selects the president — the Supreme Court justice that the president nominates."

Source: CBS News, "Face the Nation Transcripts February 14, 2016: Donald Trump, Marco Rubio," cbsnews.com, Feb. 14, 2016
Con (No)

Con
Jeb Bush
Jeb Bush
Republican

"The simple fact is the next president needs to appoint someone with a proven conservative record, similar to Justice Scalia, that is a lover of liberty, that believes in limited government, that consistently applied that kind of philosophy, that didn't try to legislator [sic] from the bench, that was respectful of the Constitution.

And then fight and fight, and fight for that nomination to make sure that that nomination passes.

Of course, the president, by the way, has every right to nominate Supreme Court justices. I'm an Article II guy in the Constitution. We're running for the president of the United States. We want a strong executive for sure. But in return for that, there should be a consensus orientation on that nomination, and there's no doubt in my mind that Barack Obama will not have a consensus pick when he submits that person to the Senate."

Source: Team Fix, "The CBS News Republican Debate Transcript, Annotated," washingtonpost.com, Feb. 13, 2016
Con
Ben Carson
Ben Carson
Republican

"In an age where it is popular to subscribe to a 'living Constitution' and during a time when political and judicial leaders prefer legal decisions that are politically convenient, Justice Scalia always dutifully carried out his responsibilities to interpret the law, not to make new ones. Time and again, he ruled based on where the black letter of the law led him, not according to the politics of the moment. For that reason, he has angered Americans on both the left and the right, but he has never wavered in his dedication to the Constitution.

It is imperative that the Senate not allow President Obama to diminish Justice Scalia's legacy by trying to nominate an individual who would carry on the President's wishes to subvert the will of the people. Given the dire condition our democracy currently finds itself under Obama's lack of leadership, I call on the Senate to stop any attempts to fill this crucial seat until We The People elect a strong Constitutionalist this November."

Source: Ben Carson for President 2016, "Statement on Justice Antonin Scalia," bencarson.com, Feb. 13, 2016
Con
Ted Cruz
Ted Cruz
Republican

"But it underscores the stakes of this election. We are one justice away from a Supreme Court that will strike down every restriction on abortion adopted by the states. We are one justice away from a Supreme Court that will reverse the Heller decision, one of Justice Scalia's seminal decisions that upheld the Second Amendment right to keep and to bear arms.

We are one justice away from a Supreme Court that would undermine the religious liberty of millions of Americans -- and the stakes of this election, for this year, for the Senate, the Senate needs to stand strong and say, 'We're not going to give up the U.S. Supreme Court for a generation by allowing Barack Obama to make one more liberal appointee.'

And then for the state of South Carolina, one of the most important judgments for the men and women of South Carolina to make is who on this stage has the background, the principle, the character, the judgment, and the strength of resolve to nominate and confirm principled constitutionalists to the court? That will be what I will do if I'm elected president."

Source: Team Fix, "The CBS News Republican Debate Transcript, Annotated," washingtonpost.com, Feb. 13, 2016
Con
John Kasich
John Kasich
Republican

“The country is so divided right now, and now we're going to see another partisan fight take place. I really wish the president would think about not nominating somebody. If you were to nominate somebody, let's have him pick somebody that's going to have unanimous approval, and such wide spread approval across the country that this could happen without a lot of recrimination. I don't think that's going to happen, and I would like the President just to for once here put the country first. We're going to have an election for President very soon, and the people will understand what is at stake in that election.

And, so I believe the President should not move forward, and I think that we ought to let the next President of the United States decide who is going to run that Supreme Court with a vote by the people of the United States of America."

Source: Team Fix, “The CBS News Republican Debate Transcript, Annotated," washingtonpost.com, Feb. 13, 2016
Con
Marco Rubio
Marco Rubio
Republican

"I do not believe the president should appoint someone. And it's not unprecedented. In fact, it has been over 80 years since a lame duck president has appointed a Supreme Court justice.

And it reminds us of this, how important this election is. Someone on this stage will get to choose the balance of the Supreme Court, and it will begin by filling this vacancy that's there now.

And we need to put people on the bench that understand that the Constitution is not a living and breathing document. It is to be interpreted as originally meant."

Source: Team Fix, "The CBS News Republican Debate Transcript, Annotated," washingtonpost.com, Feb. 13, 2016


None Found
Chris Christie
Chris Christie
Republican

Withdrew on Feb. 10, 2016; no additional research done as of that date to determine candidate's position on this question.





None Found
Carly Fiorina
Carly Fiorina
Republican

Withdrew on Feb. 10, 2016; no additional research done as of that date to determine candidate's position on this question.





None Found
Lindsey Graham
Lindsey Graham
Republican

Withdrew on Dec. 21, 2015; no additional research done as of that date to determine candidate's position on this question.





None Found
Mike Huckabee
Mike Huckabee
Republican

Withdrew on Feb. 1, 2016; no additional research done as of that date to determine candidate's position on this question.





None Found
Martin O'Malley
Martin O'Malley
Democrat

Withdrew on Feb. 1, 2016; no additional research done as of that date to determine candidate's position on this question.





None Found
Rand Paul
Rand Paul
Republican

Withdrew on Feb. 3, 2016; no additional research done as of that date to determine candidate's position on this question.








2016 Presidential Election Homepage

Quiz - Find Your Candidate Match!
Compare Candidate Positions Side-by-Side
RECOMMENDED to you...
1
Did You Know?
2
The Electoral College: Top 3 Pros and Cons
3
Pros and Cons of Donald Trump's Cabinet Picks
4
Differences in Conservative and Liberal Brains
5
Candidate Finances
6
Candidate Position Changes
7
US Political Parties
8
Presidential Election History from 1789 to 2012
9
How to Become the US President: A Step-by-Step Guide
10
Order of Presidential Succession
11
Top 10 Most Surprising Things in the 2016 Presidential Candidates' Online Stores
12
How to Register to Vote
+ DIG DEEPER...
2016 Presidential Election Results
ProCon.org Criteria for Inclusion as a Presidential Candidate
Glossary
Jeb Bush - Positions
Ben Carson - Positions
Chris Christie - Positions
Hillary Clinton - Positions
Ted Cruz - Positions
Carly Fiorina - Positions
Lindsey Graham - Positions
Mike Huckabee - Positions
John Kasich - Positions
Martin O'Malley - Positions
Rand Paul - Positions
Marco Rubio - Positions
Bernie Sanders - Positions
Donald Trump - Positions
2012 Presidential Election Quiz
CITE THIS PAGE
Who is the author?
SHARE
HOME
ABOUT
CITE THIS PAGE
REPRINTING POLICY
PRIVACY POLICY
DISCLAIMER
READER FAVORITES

State Laws
Debate Topics
Critical Thinking Quotes
Teaching Controversial Issues
History Of...
TRANSLATE
into 100+ Languages and Dialects
LET'S GET SOCIAL!
Tweets by @procon_org
ProCon.org is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit public charity.


Contact Us

233 Wilshire Blvd., Suite 200
Santa Monica, CA 90401




Natalie Leppard
Managing Editor
procon@eb.com


© 2025 ProCon.org
All rights reserved
Contact Us

ProCon/Encyclopaedia Britannica, Inc.
325 N. LaSalle Street, Suite 200
Chicago, Illinois 60654 USA


Natalie Leppard
Managing Editor
procon@eb.com


© 2025 Encyclopaedia Britannica, Inc.
All rights reserved